Joey Votto Success (Cincinnati Reds)

[bravesfan1515]

Sent: June 5th (I think) LOR, SASE, Sports Illustrated cover

Received: July 16th Sports Illustrated cover signed in blue Sharpie

Address Used: C/O Cincinnati Reds
Great American Ball Park
100 Joe Nuxhall Way
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4109

Photo:


Close-Up:

[Lincecum Fan]

That's not authentic I have gotten him ip it doesn't match

[admin]

Hi bravesfan1515

Thank you for your feedback

Would you have a scan of the envelope you received please?
If so, you are in the run for the $10 gift certificate.

Cincinnati Reds on Fanmail.biz | Previous Feedback(s) Received

Baseball / Basketball / Football Free Fan Package Addresses

Fanmail

[bravesfan1515]

That's not authentic I have gotten him ip it doesn't match

First, I never asked for authenticity comments

Second, signatures change especially when someone has time to sign instead of being rushed in a public setting (i.e Jason Heyward, Brian McCann, ect)

Third, the signature matches his certified autos and he just started responding so I have no reason to believe that he all of a sudden got a "ghost signer"

[vjw0307]

Doesn't look far off but he's not known for sending authentics TTM...regardless, looks a lot more authentic than the one I got back!

[NRC Collectibles]

You dont have to ask for authenticity posts. People can post it if they want to. With that said, they are fake. All the returns coming back this year are fake. 2-3 years ago they were real. These new ones looks nothing like his ip ones and he never signs that small. If anything, his graph does not fit on most cards. Whoever is signing his stuff is copying his cetified sticker stuff where he had less room to sign and they can't even get the sig fully right. Sorry to tell you, but you did not get "Joey Votto" on your item.

[bravesfan1515]

Since you all know your stuff can you tell me if this is real? It is supposed to be Scottie Pippen


and this one is supposed to be Kevin Greene

[NRC Collectibles]

Pipp looks like it was signed with a shit pen and he had to put effort into it looking good but still is pippen. So the pippen is good. Dont know who kevin greene is so I am not familiar with the sig. But the votto doesn't change because you think you are being cute about other graphs. These Vottos are not real. Why would he alternate between two complete different signatures during the season. His ttm doesn't even look similiar at all to his ip right now, never mind it being him actually signing the stuff. It has to be close to arguable.

[bravesfan1515]

You know, it is certain people on this board that make it hard to post here. Contrary to popular belief, not everyone wants or cares for the opinions of those who troll the board looking to put their two cents into everyone's post.

[Davidium]

You asked him to tell you if they were real. He told you what his opinion was on them. Why do you treat it like a no-dip kind of thing. You should be glad you got something back; instead you just complain because one guy gave you his opinion. As long as it's real to you, that's all that matters. Unless you're one of those guys about to put it on ebay, what's the deal.