kenzie8201 wrote:Actually I've seen him recommended many times from experienced collectors at Star Archive. Not to mention the fact that he uses the photos over and over again proves NOTHING. Why would someone do this??? I don't mean to be rude but the answer is pretty obvious because for anyone who does a lot of in-person collecting knows that it is IMPOSSIBLE to get them to take a picture with you, some won't even let you. He is showing the same pictures to prove that he does infact collect these in-person.
I have to disagree with people on here who are so quick to jump without a whole lot to back up thier reasons with....
He'd be able to get more than one photo if he'd met that that many times.
You say the people who doubt theyre legit have no proof, well...neither do you.
His private feedback and repeated use of the same photos is evidence pointing towards fakes.
A picture that proves he met a celeb AT ONE TIME doesnt prove that piece is legit.
And to the newbie who said "no fakes are that good", well, that doesnt really resemble her full autograph at all, so please dont comment when you dont have much experience.
Like I said, i welcome full discusiion on this, but so far NO names have come up as to who recommends them. Why not? If MANY people recommend them, why have we not even had one reliable name crop up yet?
That person is not a newbie and I hope you're an expert on Jennifer Aniston's autograph because it's obvious that you aren't on Christina Aguliera considering that is one of the worst fakes I have even seen in my entire life.... WOW. Sorry, but you feel that you can go on and on about legit sellers and you have an obvious fake as your signature.
Ok, as for names?? like wtf??? That is a joke to me... Ok Sally, Bob and Henry, like as if you would know who recommended people. It's just stupid. EVEN if people had recommended this seller, which is how most of us have found this seller, that wouldn't mean it was legit.. It's the fact that he has so many pictures and his signatures are dead on. Sorry sweetie.
Andy316 wrote:
He'd be able to get more than one photo if he'd met that that many times.
You say the people who doubt theyre legit have no proof, well...neither do you.
His private feedback and repeated use of the same photos is evidence pointing towards fakes.
A picture that proves he met a celeb AT ONE TIME doesnt prove that piece is legit.
And to the newbie who said "no fakes are that good", well, that doesnt really resemble her full autograph at all, so please dont comment when you dont have much experience.
Like I said, i welcome full discusiion on this, but so far NO names have come up as to who recommends them. Why not? If MANY people recommend them, why have we not even had one reliable name crop up yet?
Why would he be able to get more photos? Do you think Angelina Jolie has the time to stop and pose for photos everytime she signs? How about Julia Roberts, who has 10 rows of people at the stage door of her Broadway play wanting an autograph? Yeah, how rude of her not to pose with each and every person there! And how dare she not inscribe every photo!!!
He has NO private feedback. I can CLEARLY see his feedback. Am I missing something here?
Not upset that you believe my autograph is fake. While I RESPECT your opinion, I also feel I have the right to give my own. I do appreciate all of your opinions, those who feel it is authentic and those who don't. I do have the opportunity to receive a refund and I'm not going to. I'm satisfied. If you are satisfied with your XTina....then so be it. And saying I'm a "bad" member, when I'm simply giving my opinion? No need to be judgemental. Thanks everyone!
I ask that a moderator for this forum lock this post???
HayleyR210 wrote:Not upset that you believe my autograph is fake. While I RESPECT your opinion, I also feel I have the right to give my own. I do appreciate all of your opinions, those who feel it is authentic and those who don't. I do have the opportunity to receive a refund and I'm not going to. I'm satisfied. If you are satisfied with your XTina....then so be it. And saying I'm a "bad" member, when I'm simply giving my opinion? No need to be judgemental. Thanks everyone!
I ask that a moderator for this forum lock this post???
Ive heard the Xtina comment before, but it was got IP, so it p**ses me off when I get told its fake, seeing as it...not.
Andy316 wrote:A moderator doesnt like being told her auto is fake so she tries to turn it round by saying one of mine is fake. How original. And I thought Moderators were supposed to be good members
Not sure how an IP can be fake
You're cracking me up... What is your issue with this seller? Show me what is fake and examples of authentic ones.. Because I can do this and I have a feeling you can't so much... But you're cute all the same. Our proof is his proof. Great feedback, pictures, reputation and signatures that match. So, just incase you haven't figured this out yet, it is YOUR job to make a GOOD agruement as to why you feel he is not legit.. Or you do what your mother taught you when you were just little and not speak if you don't have anything nice to say
Andy316 wrote:Someone with FOUR POSTS isnt a newbie? WTF? Yes they are.
I'll say it again - how can an IP be fake?
I may be a newbie at this board, but I've been collecting for 7 1/2 years. And yes, I'm sure that Christina was signed in person by SOMEONE, just not her.
Andy316 wrote:Someone with FOUR POSTS isnt a newbie? WTF? Yes they are.
I'll say it again - how can an IP be fake?
I may be a newbie at this board, but I've been collecting for 7 1/2 years. And yes, I'm sure that Christina was signed in person by SOMEONE, just not her.
Very funny. Its been signed in person by HER, not someone else.
Andy316 wrote:Someone with FOUR POSTS isnt a newbie? WTF? Yes they are.
I'll say it again - how can an IP be fake?
I may be a newbie at this board, but I've been collecting for 7 1/2 years. And yes, I'm sure that Christina was signed in person by SOMEONE, just not her.
Very funny. Its been signed in person by HER, not someone else.
Where is your photo of her signing that photo? because we now know that you have to have that for anything to be authentic.
Andy316 wrote:A moderator doesnt like being told her auto is fake so she tries to turn it round by saying one of mine is fake. How original. And I thought Moderators were supposed to be good members
Not sure how an IP can be fake
You're cracking me up... What is your issue with this seller? Show me what is fake and examples of authentic ones.. Because I can do this and I have a feeling you can't so much... But you're cute all the same. Our proof is his proof. Great feedback, pictures, reputation and signatures that match. So, just incase you haven't figured this out yet, it is YOUR job to make a GOOD agruement as to why you feel he is not legit.. Or you do what your mother taught you when you were just little and not speak if you don't have anything nice to say
I dont HAVE an issue with this seller.
Great feedback? Means nothing.
Pics that he met a celeb once? means nothing
sigs that match? not quite
reputation? debateable.
Your argument is theoretically as weak as mine, but at least ive put some solid facts out there, all you've done is argue and throw "er..its real cuz it is" comments around.
Until YOU can come up with a genuine response to keep this debate alive, I wont refer to you again, as you clearly have no clue what you're on about.
Upload your pictures here: 
