I sent you a PM in reply to your other, ... but if you check here first

.
DO NOT request that the stage manager go hunting around for your autographs. That's NOT their job -- lucky enough to have them do the cast-signed...they need not find actors and have them signed things so people can save a few bucks. If you want an autograph from a star, you send them a letter. Some "stars" of shows will send cast-signed without requesting, but also DO NOT request a cast-signed from an actor/actress. It's low and makes it seem like you're out for a cheap autograph. Please keep in mind these are people, they don't get paid as good as other actors, and most of them actually read their letters and it gets them through the tough 8-performance-a-week show.
If you want, for example, a cast-signed Phantom of the Opera playbill and star Marni Raab's on another, .. then you simply have to write two requests in two seperate envelopes. Again, a stage manager is not a PA nor agent nor manager nor whatever for actors; they have their own job: keeping up with the show/etc.
Just request a signed playbill from the actor/actress at the end of your note. Most will either send a playbill anyway, or a headshot.
MissMaexox:
Thanks for responding, but I think you should just get some facts straight (not to sound like a know-it-all...you did say you never did this before):
-Address it to the STAGE MANAGER, or Cast & Crew would work as well; Stage Manager is usually more appropriate.
-It's 2-3 stamps for a NYC-US. Playbills can manage anywhere from $.75-$1.10.
-A playbill will absolutely never fit in a 5x7. 6x9 is the bare minimum - it JUST fits one perfectly.
-You can attempt to request multiple (such as 2?), but I wouldn't reccomend it. The cast-signed playbill "industry" is QUICKLY failing thanks to people on this board, and especially thanks to eBay. Some shows will, plenty shows will not.
-"I think they get rid of the leftovers. You'd probably get an RTS anyway, since the post office knows it's closed, and they wouldn't deliver the request. I just wouldn't do that"
You wouldn't get an RTS - you'd get no news. ***SOMETIMES*** in ***EXTREMELY*** **Rare** cases sometimes cast-signeds are left-over, or just blank playbills, but generally no. I've seen one pure success on this board from it, and I've come up short 2/3 times (and waiting on that 3rd one believe it or not).
When a show closes, everything is loaded out, and whatever is left (ie: a chair in a dressing room - the Al Hirschfeld for example apparently has lots of stuff from Curtains still in it) is either trashed or re-used. Clearly, "A Tale of Two Cities" wouldn't be giving out "Curtains" playbills, nor would "Hair" most likely be giving out 'Tale' ones.
The post office, unfortunately, could care entirely less that a show closed. When a show closes, the theatre doesn't close, which is why it's important to address a show with it's theatre name as well.
Examples:
Stage Manager of
"West Side Story"
c/o Palace Theatre
or
Stephanie J. Block
'9to5'
c/o the Marquis Theatre
Good luck!