As far as I've been able to discern, the feedback forum is not about successes and failures, nor is it about whether the autograph is genuine or not. It's about the addresses in the database. The folks running the site are asking for feedback on whether the address listed for each celebrity is accurate and/or current. Whether you get a success or a failure is a whole 'nother topic.

unless someone puts in the time and effort to show proof of a success ie , photo, i don't think it should be listed under successes-when it comes down to it a lot of the successes around here could go uncounted -jmo

This would create the inevitable problem of unnecessary arguments, something this forum already has too much of.

[quote="Icena"][quote="Jaffer"]Perhaps authentic/ non authentic?[/quote]

Hmm, that's a pretty good idea![/quote]

The problem with that is that then you have to have someone saying what is and isnt authentic. Arguments are going to ensue regarding sec/non sec, people who think it's authentic and they have a PP or an AP etc. Someone is going to have to move all these to the right section... it's a huge undertaking.

[quote="Jaffer"]Perhaps authentic/ non authentic?[/quote]

Hmm, that's a pretty good idea!

Perhaps authentic/ non authentic?

Not a bad idea, but it might be a bit hard to classify successes/failures. What if someone receives a PP back? Is that a success or a failure? It's different for different people.

Hi,
I think we should divide the feedback's section to two groups : a)successes b)failures
What do you think about this idea?